Craig Gillespie's "Supergirl" arrives in theaters June 26 with a decidedly mixed critical reception. Early reviews from film critics praise the casting choices while offering reservations about the film itself.
Millie Alcock carries the title role following her Superman cameo last summer, earning widespread compliments from critics who see her performance as a bright spot in the DC Studios entry. Jason Momoa's turn as Lobo also draws positive notice, with reviewers highlighting his charisma in the supporting role. David Corenswet's Superman appearance generates particular enthusiasm, with some critics calling it "peak casting" for the character, suggesting DC Studios nailed this major casting decision.
The mixed verdict reflects a pattern in DC's recent theatrical output. While individual performances garner praise, the films themselves often struggle with execution and narrative coherence. Alcock's star power and Momoa's scene-stealing work cannot entirely compensate for what critics perceive as broader structural issues within the film.
Corenswet's Superman praise carries special weight given the character's importance to DC's cinematic universe rebuild under James Gunn and Peter Safran's leadership. The critical enthusiasm for his portrayal suggests the studio made a sound choice for its flagship hero, even if "Supergirl" itself proves uneven.
The film marks another test of DC Studios' ability to balance character-driven performances with coherent storytelling. Strong casting choices have become the studio's calling card, yet critical reception remains tempered by questions about script, direction, and overall filmmaking craft. Alcock, Momoa, and Corenswet emerge as the clear winners from early screenings, even as the film itself divides opinion.