According to the Wall Street Journal report earlier this month, the White House is considering an executive order that would strip nonprofits deemed to have alleged 'terrorist ties' of their tax-exempt status. If enacted, this measure would authorize the president to label nonprofits that are allegedly 'supporting or engaging in terrorist activity' under Section 501(p)(2)(C) of the United States Internal Revenue Code, immediately suspending their tax-exempt status. For arts and culture organizations already operating on razor-thin margins, this represents an existential threat—not because they harbor terrorists, but because the standard is dangerously undefined.

The White House has not made an official confirmation of the measure. A spokesperson told Hyperallergic that 'any policy announcements will come directly from the President,' and 'discussions about potential decisions or their impacts are otherwise baseless speculation.' This non-denial is precisely the problem. Arts organizations cannot adequately prepare for or defend themselves against a policy that remains simultaneously imminent and unconfirmed, vague in definition and sweeping in scope.

The danger lies not in the stated purpose but in the mechanism. What constitutes 'alleged' terrorist ties? Who determines this? What appeals process exists? The arts world has long grappled with complex questions about boycotts, free speech, and institutional responsibility. These conversations matter. But they cannot happen through executive fiat. They require transparency, public debate, and clear standards—none of which an executive order provides.

History shows that vague authority over nonprofit status invites abuse. Arts organizations that advocate for Palestinian rights, that support controversial artists, or that simply displease those in power could find themselves labeled without due process. The chilling effect alone would be devastating: institutions would self-censor not out of legal obligation but out of fear, knowing that the threshold for losing tax-exempt status is undefined.

If the Trump administration believes specific organizations are genuinely supporting terrorist activity, existing legal frameworks already address this. The government can prosecute criminal activity. It can designate foreign terrorist organizations. It need not resort to stripping tax-exempt status from domestic nonprofits based on 'alleged' ties under a vague executive order.

Arts and culture organizations deserve clarity and due process, not speculation and fear. If this order is coming, it should be announced plainly, debated openly, and subject to judicial review. The arts need certainty to survive. Right now, they're being asked to operate in the dark.